facebook twitter instagram linkedin google youtube vimeo tumblr yelp rss email podcast phone blog search brokercheck brokercheck Play Pause
Should You Delay Social Security and Use Portfolio Withdrawals First? Thumbnail

Should You Delay Social Security and Use Portfolio Withdrawals First?

ONE-SENTENCE ANSWER   |  Delaying Social Security can be reasonable when the household can fund spending during the wait and values higher future benefits, but the additional portfolio withdrawals, taxes and survivor consequences must be considered together.

Key Takeaways

  • A later claiming date may increase the monthly Social Security benefit, but it also means receiving fewer benefit payments early on.
  • The household must identify how much more the portfolio would need to supply during the delay period.
  • Withdrawal-account choices, Social Security taxation and Medicare premium effects can change the comparison across years.
  • For couples, the effect on a potential surviving spouse deserves separate attention.

Introduction

A retiree may reach Social Security eligibility with enough investment assets to postpone claiming. The higher benefit available later can be appealing, especially when retirement could last many years. But waiting does not eliminate the need to fund spending today.

A later claiming date changes the responsibility assigned to the portfolio during the intervening years. The decision is therefore not only about whether a future Social Security check will be larger. It is also about whether the household wants—and can reasonably support—the additional withdrawals required before that check begins.

What changes when you claim Social Security later?

Under current Social Security rules, retirement benefits can begin as early as age 62, with a reduction for claiming before full retirement age. Claiming after full retirement age earns delayed retirement credits up to age 70. The monthly benefit can therefore be higher at a later claiming age, but no additional delayed retirement credits accumulate after age 70.

Waiting means giving up payments that could have been received earlier in exchange for a larger monthly benefit once payments start. Those choices may produce different lifetime totals depending on how long the person receives benefits. Neither outcome is known in advance.

The decision should be evaluated using the individual’s actual Social Security estimates and claiming eligibility. The size of the higher future benefit depends on the person’s earnings record, full retirement age and proposed start dates.

Begin with the spending gap during the waiting years

The Spending Requirement establishes how much support is needed each year. Income Architecture then distinguishes the dependable income available before claiming from the part of spending that must be funded by investments.

Consider an illustrative household with $9,000 in monthly spending requirements and $4,000 of pension and other dependable monthly income. Without Social Security, the portfolio must cover about $5,000 per month before considering differences in taxes or unusual expenses. If an early claiming option would provide an illustrative $3,000 monthly Social Security payment, the immediate portfolio requirement might instead be about $2,000 per month.

In that simplified comparison, waiting would require approximately $3,000 more from the portfolio each month. Over three years, that is roughly $108,000 of additional withdrawals before investment returns, changes in spending, taxes or other adjustments. The $3,000 benefit is an example rather than a Social Security estimate; an actual decision requires the person’s benefit figures.

The point is not that the additional withdrawals make delay unreasonable. It is that those withdrawals must be recognized as part of the decision, not treated as an incidental detail.

A higher later benefit has a present funding cost

A higher monthly benefit can reduce the amount the portfolio needs to supply in later years. That may be valuable for someone expecting a long retirement or placing greater weight on dependable income later in life.

The tradeoff is that the portfolio must provide more cash during the waiting period. If markets decline early in retirement, taking larger withdrawals can leave fewer assets available when markets recover. The household may choose to use assets already positioned for near-term spending or may need to adjust other uses of the portfolio to fund the delay.

Investment Alignment considers whether those near-term withdrawals can be supported without compromising the assets responsible for later spending, tax flexibility or long-term growth. The question is not whether a particular allocation is “correct,” but whether the investment structure can fulfill the specific income responsibilities created by the claiming choice.

Tax timing may change the comparison

Social Security benefits may be partly taxable depending on the household’s other income and filing status. A traditional IRA withdrawal used to cover the waiting period is generally taxable to the extent it represents deductible contributions and earnings. A taxable-account sale may recognize capital gains or losses, while a qualified Roth IRA distribution can have a different tax result.

Delaying Social Security can also change the years in which other income is recognized. Some households may have more flexibility to consider Roth conversions or other withdrawals before benefits begin. Others may find that larger portfolio distributions during the delay period create costs or crowd out choices they had expected to make.

For Medicare beneficiaries, higher income in a given tax year can also affect income-related Part B and Part D premiums in a later year. The usual determination relies on tax information from two years earlier, although exceptions and revised determinations may apply. Tax Sequencing therefore compares outcomes across years, not solely the current federal tax bracket.

Delaying benefits does not automatically mean paying less tax. It changes the timing and mix of income, which may help or hurt depending on the household’s facts.

For couples, distinguish spousal and survivor benefits

The claiming decision can affect more than the worker whose benefit is delayed. A higher worker benefit earned through delayed retirement credits can increase the benefit that may be available to a surviving spouse, subject to the survivor’s circumstances and claiming rules.

That is different from an ordinary spousal benefit while both spouses are alive, which is generally based on the worker’s full-retirement-age benefit rather than the increased amount attributable to delayed retirement credits. The distinction is especially important when the higher-earning spouse is considering delay.

The household should also consider what happens to spending, pension income, taxes and portfolio withdrawals after the first spouse dies. A survivor-focused reason for delay can be meaningful, but it does not eliminate the cost of funding the waiting period.

When might earlier claiming be reasonable?

Earlier claiming can be reasonable when current spending needs are pressing, when additional withdrawals would put too much pressure on investment assets, when health or expected benefit duration changes the household’s priorities, or when dependable income today is worth more to the household than the potential later increase.

Later claiming may be reasonable when the household can meet its interim spending needs, the portfolio has an appropriate role in funding the delay, and the higher later benefit serves a meaningful income or survivor objective.

Neither conclusion should depend on a single break-even age. Comparing a few plausible retirement lengths, withdrawal patterns and tax circumstances usually reveals more about the decision than one lifetime-total calculation.

Reassess portfolio responsibilities after benefits begin

Once Social Security begins, the share of spending assigned to the portfolio may decline. That can create room to rebuild reserves, reposition investments for later responsibilities or change the timing of other planned distributions.

The decision also warrants review before benefits begin if spending, health, investment values or household circumstances change materially. Coordinating the claiming date over time is not the same as assuming the original date must be maintained regardless of what happens.

In Summary

Delaying Social Security is a decision to accept more portfolio-funded spending now in exchange for a potentially larger source of dependable income later. Whether that exchange is reasonable depends on the household’s spending needs, other income, withdrawal sources, investment responsibilities and potential survivor benefits.

A useful analysis makes both sides of that exchange visible instead of treating the larger future benefit as the whole answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does waiting until age 70 guarantee more lifetime Social Security income?

No. Waiting can increase the monthly benefit, but it also means fewer payments in the early years. Total benefits received depend on how long payments continue and other claiming circumstances.

Do I have to wait until age 70 if I decide not to claim at full retirement age?

No. An eligible person may choose a start date after full retirement age and before age 70. Delayed retirement credits accumulate during that period, subject to Social Security rules, but stop at age 70.

Does delaying my benefit increase what my spouse can receive?

It may affect a surviving spouse’s benefit because delayed retirement credits can be reflected in survivor calculations. Regular spousal benefits while both spouses are alive use different rules and generally do not increase with the worker’s delayed retirement credits.

If I delay Social Security, should I also delay Medicare?

Not automatically. Medicare enrollment operates under separate rules. Eligibility and enrollment timing at age 65 should be evaluated even when Social Security retirement benefits will begin later, including any applicable employer-coverage exceptions.

Continue Learning

How Do I Create Reliable Income in Retirement?

This article explains the income structure within which a Social Security claiming date must operate.

Why Retirement Tax Planning Is Really About Timing

It explains why the timing of income recognition can change later tax and Medicare consequences.

Longevity Risk: What Changes When Retirement Lasts Longer Than Expected?

A longer retirement changes how households evaluate dependable income and future portfolio responsibilities.